i dont think its roger cause there was a pic of him on another syte
careforcheeseandcrackers?: on 01/05/2007
i think this is tony in the back alleys when he meets ms. coulter for the first time
actually.: on 01/06/2007
on goldencompassmovie.com this image is shown and rogers name is mentioned along with the gobblers... and about how lyra is to go after him.
randomperson: on 01/06/2007
that's what I was about to say. I've seen quite a few of these pictures before.
northen_lights_rocks: on 01/06/2007
my bet is on tony, because in the book we read about tony being kidnapped and mrs coulter seeing him, but we don't see mrs coulter take roger
marley: on 01/08/2007
this one looks good, either if it's tony or roger, but i think it's tony
EharfedaleRED: on 01/10/2007
It's Roger guys. Still looks to 'mouse-like' to me. Should be odler as well... Still, it's be okay, the setting and acting looks quite good.
Jordan college girl: on 01/10/2007
Dun, dun, dun, dun. The Gobblers are coming!
marissacoulter: on 01/11/2007
It's Roger. The actor's name is Ben Walker, he's a friend of my cousin.
Scoresby Inc: on 01/12/2007
this can't be Roger. Goger is supposed to be from our world and so, not dressed as if he lived in the 1950's. Also, Roger is not supposed to appear in the first film as he does not appear in the Northern Lights
glittercloud: on 01/12/2007
read the title. ROOOOOOGGGGERRRRRR
god. he does appear in northern lights. Golden compass, northern lights. Same book
Reedie_Belacqua: on 01/12/2007
Scoresby inc, I can't believe yu confused roger with Will xD
Reedie_Belacqua: on 01/12/2007
And you think Northern Lights it's the Subtle Knife, as glittercloud said, Goldem Compass is Northern Lights...
I think you forgot lots of things about HDM
or maybe you didn't pay attetion while you were reading? (?)
siiknezz: on 01/15/2007
i want a better name =D
Buzz: on 01/25/2007
read the title of the photo of course its roger
Tarantinoand: on 01/27/2007
I don't think this is Roger... This must be Tony Makkarios, the first boy we hear be kidnapped...
AJM: on 01/29/2007
I think this is Bulwarks Lane in Oxford, an alleyway that runs from George Street to New Road - and which has something of a dangerous reputation.
Lyra at heart age 13: on 01/30/2007
*Sighs heavily* It is Roger. Read the title.
Lori: on 01/30/2007
GOBBLER BAIT!
Alanna: on 01/31/2007
Scene looks perfect and dangerous. which is the case of tony and roger when they get captured anyway so it doesn't matter. it achieves the effect.
Random boy: on 02/03/2007
Random boy: on 02/03/2007
Random boy: on 02/03/2007
left foot james: on 02/03/2007
Its Roger because the actor is my mate from school and he told me everything about the cast
Lyra116: on 02/04/2007
it's roger
reachin4thestars: on 02/05/2007
hasnt anyone bothered to look above the pic where it clearly says ROGER!
Emily: on 02/08/2007
Ooohhhh its Roger! Its soooo cute%
Emily: on 02/08/2007
Ooohhhh its Roger! Its soooo cute! Poor Roger:(
L!BBY: on 02/09/2007
he looks soo clueless! omg...its sooo funny!
4getregret: on 02/10/2007
NO!!! My image of how Roger looked is ruined!!! :(
Isabelle: on 02/13/2007
This is Roger, but not how this is how I thought he would look.
...: on 02/15/2007
plz dont be roger... plz
hb: on 02/16/2007
why cant they get anyone except mrs coulter right??????
Lyra at heart age 13: on 02/16/2007
erm... hb I think that mrs Coulter is the one they got the most wrong appearence wise (not that I care coz Nicole Kidman is perfect to play her) She is meant to have black hair and brown eyes not blond hair and Blue eyes. Although you probably wouldnt know that because it seems that you havnt read the books lol
Pan_Kirjava_Isabelle: on 02/16/2007
Yes, they should have gotten Kidman a black wig or something....
Reedie_Belacqua: on 02/16/2007
nooo
a wig would look weird >.<
She could dyed it!
But well....
I gotta confess i prefer her Blond, because i imagined her blond and blue eyes. (and I knew it was wrong, but i couldnt help it)
But, i guess things must be how they should
But, it' nicole kidman!
as i've always said, i've always though she was perfect for the role!!
AND she's a great actrees, SHE'S AWESOME!
Pan_Kirjava_Isabelle: on 02/16/2007
Yes, Nicole is great for the part!!!!!!!
Oh yeah- Will someone shut hb up?!
Lyra at heart age 13: on 02/17/2007
lol Pan_Kirjava_Isabelle! I think he will once he has realised his mistakes ! Nicole is perfect blond hair or not !
Pan_Kirjava_Isabelle: on 02/17/2007
Yes! I couldn't think of anyone better then Nicole!
Wouldn't it be SOOOOO funny if they made Kiera Knightly (or however you spell her name) Mrs.Coulter!
Someone in my school thought they should have....
Weird..... She also thought Lyra should be Dakota Fanning....
Something is SO wrong with her....
Reedie_Belacqua: on 02/17/2007
"Wouldn't it be SOOOOO funny if they made Kiera Knightly "
I would have the urgency of murder them.. ?ɬ?,?ɬ?
I don't like that actrees at all ?Ǭ¨?Ǭ¨'
And Dakota Fanning, she's a great actrees, but a horrible lyra
Pan_Kirjava_Isabelle: on 02/17/2007
I know. It would be really funny, though!!
Yes, could you just imagine Dakota Fanning as Lyra?! *shudders*
Second thought, don't imagine it!
I like Dakota Fanning in Uptown s, though.
Pan_Kirjava_Isabelle: on 02/17/2007
Oh yeah. I can't say gurl.
*Uptown Gurls...
Reedie_Belacqua: on 02/18/2007
i like her too in that movie
I liked the song at the end :) lol
aand molly (molly?) smiles! ~~~
dakota br... i want to see her on move!
i want a trailerrrr
Pan_Kirjava_Isabelle: on 02/18/2007
In Uptown Gurls, she was so funny acting all mature and stuff!!
And I love Molly, too.
I want to see the movie and a trailer SO bad, too!!!
I really can't wait until they pick the guy for Will!!!!!!!!
I've only seen the (fake) trailers on here. They're just bad...
Lyra at heart age 13: on 02/18/2007
OMG I can't even begin to fathom what a travesty they would make this movie if they cast KEIRA KNIGHTLY as mrs Coulter. Especially with that stupid pout thing she has got going... what the hell is that all about?! As for Dakota Fanning... if there is one thing they want to avoid, its making this film as cheesy and stupid as they made the Narnia film and by casting Dakota as Lyra, they would succeed in doing just that to our brloved HDM. Also, would Dakota Fanning be able to pull off a convincing common english girl accent? Thank god they didn't cast Emma Watson (Hermione Granger) as Lyra like someone commented on another picture, we really would be screwed then !! btw I have never seen Uptown gurls, sounds good, I'll have to rent it!!
: on 02/18/2007
*beloved
Pan_Kirjava_Isabelle: on 02/18/2007
Emma Watson! No way!!?? I mean, she's a good actress, but not Lyra and WAY too old. That would have been as terrible as Dakota Fanning or Keira Knightly.
Uptown Gurls (with an i) is great!!! You have to rent it.
But, can you just imagine Keira....? She's SO skinny and well... just SO not right for the part. It's kinda scary...
Reedie_Belacqua: on 02/18/2007
i agree with you two..
if they were to do that, would you join with me and go kill them all?
xD
i don't think (in my opinion) that emma watson is a good actress, sorry,
she's over dramatic.. i dunno.
I liked how she looked in the frst movie, but later her hair wasn't messy anymore ?ɬ?,o
Pan_Kirjava_Isabelle: on 02/18/2007
If they did do that we would march into the set and start screaming. We would demand that they would fire Emma or we would kill them. LOL!!
I agree, she is a little too dramatic...
Lyra at heart age 13: on 02/19/2007
Lol ! Death to those who cast Emma Watson!! I agree that Emma Watson is over dramatic, but I have only seen her acting in the Harry Potter films as Hermione, and her character is waaaaaaaaay too over dramatic anyway ! So maybe it is just the character she is playing that makes her over dramatic. Also she IS way to old and looks absolutely nothing like Lyra, as Reedie said, she hasn't even got the messy hair anymore!!
above: on 02/19/2007
We have to all go down to the studios if they cast wrong for Will !!
Pan_Kirjava_Isabelle: on 02/19/2007
I know! I can't wait to see who they pick for Will. Yeah, Emma's too old and not like Lyra. I would be SO mad! I guess Hermione's dramatic because in the books she is.
Reedie_Belacqua: on 02/23/2007
she is, but emma plays her too dramatic
Lyra_B_S: on 02/24/2007
I WILL join you, Reedie!!!
Pan_Kirjava_Isabelle: on 02/25/2007
me too!!
Lyra at heart age 13: on 02/25/2007
I'll third that! We could start the revolution here!!
plaidskirtedheros: on 02/25/2007
ditto, glittercloud
plaidskirtedheros: on 02/25/2007
goosebumps rising!!! why isn't today december 7?????????????!!!!!!!!!
Pan_Kijava_Isabelle: on 03/01/2007
I saw Daniel and Nicole presenting at the Oscars together and they look fantastic together!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Thor: on 03/06/2007
This boy is perfect- the picture really captures the element of Roger. I love the costume and the picture. Unfortunately the set looks a little off.
Agree with the emma wwatson thing- she drives me up the wall. Hermione should be more weird and bushy haired.
Gyptian_Queen: on 03/12/2007
He looks so lost! but also alot different from the other pic of roger, i take back what i said before. I'll join that revolution, i think they really screwed up harry potter especially with emma watson she's such a drama queen. And don't get me started on her eyes brows! it's like they have a life of their own.
Lyra at heart age 13: on 03/13/2007
lol! Good one Gyptian Queen!! Its like they're ready to jump out of the screen at you at any moment!
Thor: on 03/17/2007
Thor: on 03/17/2007
Has anybody read that 'Emma Watson is growing up beautiful infront of the camera' article in the paper. I very almost puked when I read that. Smother anyone in makeup, air brushing and hair product and they will 'grow up beautiful'. I hate girls covered in all that crud.
And just out of interest will they airbrush Dakota when(/if) she gets acne---?
Lyra at heart age 13: on 03/24/2007
I'll second that comment Thor, i personally cannot stand make up and air brushing. It so freeking fake. I think that Dakota should have a few spots by the third film any way as she is "reaching adolesence", major part of the book if you havn't noticed, and Lyra would not worry herself about such things as covering or hiding spots any way.
above: on 03/24/2007
Please don't turn Lyra in to a Barbie doll, when the girl they got is so perfect for her role naturally (in my eyes of course)
Thor: on 03/24/2007
Interestingly enough if this film is anything to go by it will take until Dakota is 17 to finish filming
Anna (moomin): on 04/13/2007
i know that's why they had to cast her soo young. Can you imagine if they casted someone a lot older, they would proberbly be in their 20's by the third film, and that would be just dreadful.
Anna (moomin): on 04/13/2007
I kind of imagined Roger being more mature looking, and well old enough to be a kitchen boy. It look's like he could proberbly just look over the counter, let alone do anything else.
Pan_Kirjava_Isabelle: on 04/13/2007
Roger and Dakota both look too young. It will be hard with the love Lyra has with Will in the third book.
Lyra at heart age 13: on 04/20/2007
Well maybe people still reading the books should come on this website, it is to be expected you know seeing as we discuss the book ALL the time. Oh yeah people make your mind up. One minute you say Dakota will be too old by the third film and the next you say she looks to young to pul off a convincing love story. ????????
Witch-Queen: on 04/21/2007
I just finished reading the books for a second time, I LOVE them!
Lyra at heart age 13: on 04/22/2007
Good on you Witch_Queen!! I am just on my third way round!! They are the greatest works of literay genius EVER!! THEY ROCK!!!! k I am done.
Pan_Kirjava_Isabelle: on 04/25/2007
I think Dakota is just NOT lyra.
Lyra&Pan: on 06/04/2007
Roger CAN NOT be played by this baby over here!!! He looks like a five year old!!!
Witch_Queen: on 06/07/2007
Yes! I agree with you Lyra&Pan! He looks too young!
Lyra&Pan: on 06/07/2007
I mean, I always imagined Lyra's friends around 10 to 12, not 5 to 7, dang !!!
Lyra&Pan: on 06/10/2007
I never noticed his nose...
Lyra&Pan: on 06/11/2007
I just copared it with other Roger shots.
Lyra&Pan: on 06/12/2007
Generaly yes, I've won some drawing awards in school competitions.
Lyra&Pan: on 06/13/2007
I've thrown them away coz..it's a long story.
Lyra&Pan: on 06/15/2007
Will you send it here? I want to draw Lyra, but I can't find the right clothes.
Lyra&Pan: on 06/16/2007
I want to make her wearing a lylac, dirty dress and a white, even dirtier apron. I have some trouble with the dress's length.
Fallen Authority: on 06/19/2007
Does his size or age matter? Roger is going to die in the end and is not really a primary character of the story. I wonder would will play the role of Will though as I have some expectations to see from the boy who play as him.
Lyra&Pan: on 06/20/2007
Everyine has expectations from everyone.
Lyra&Pan: on 06/21/2007
Yeah, a rip...and maybe without shoes..Hmmm
Lyra&Pan: on 06/21/2007
Yea,cool.
qwertyuiopasdfghjklzxcvbnm: on 06/22/2007
he looks so young!!!
Lyra at heart age 13: on 06/27/2007
Yeah, I really don't like that kid. He over acts too sweet, and he totally ruined the character of Charlie.
Ama: on 07/02/2007
That's how I imagined Pan's voice. He always seemed like a somewhat authoritative figure to Lyra, always warning her not to do bad things and whatnot.
Ama: on 07/06/2007
Well since adults are more authoritative, naturally they'd pick an adult.
drama queen: on 07/07/2007
dis looks like the path that goes round ely cathedral..............
Ama: on 07/09/2007
Are you sure? I've just checked the official Golden Compass site, and they have Adam Godley for Pantalaimon still. Personally, I think Freddie Highmore would stink for the part. :P
Ama: on 07/10/2007
/This/ is for italicizing. Not real italicizing but you get the point.
Ama: on 07/10/2007
I really hope they don't change it. But I'm still not sure they're actually going to.
Ama: on 07/11/2007
I guess I could. But it seems a little too forceful. =/
Ama: on 07/16/2007
I wonder if they're going to actually show Roger being taken by the Gobblers in the movie.
Ama: on 07/31/2007
You can tell they are trying to keep faithfully to the story overall. They talked with Pullman himself and everything. I really don't mind if they change the name of a minor character or two.
Anyway, what did you guys think of the extended preview? I don't think I've been so excited for this since I first heard it would become a movie!
Ama: on 08/02/2007
Must there always be an argument?
If you like the book so much why does it matter what everyone else thinks of it? Why does it matter how Dakota acts *outside* of the movie?
Anyway, at first I wasn't sure about the idea of Freddie Highmore for Pan's voice. But now I'm glad they did it because then we can hear Pan's voice and manner develop as Lyra's does. I also have more faith in the actors for Lee and John Faa. =]
Ama: on 08/05/2007
Hmm. Interesting.
His looks seem fine for it. But he doesn't seem creepy in the right way. Lol.
Kevin: on 01/04/2007
Silverfist: on 01/05/2007
sophie: on 01/05/2007
careforcheeseandcrackers?: on 01/05/2007
actually.: on 01/06/2007
randomperson: on 01/06/2007
northen_lights_rocks: on 01/06/2007
marley: on 01/08/2007
EharfedaleRED: on 01/10/2007
Jordan college girl: on 01/10/2007
marissacoulter: on 01/11/2007
Scoresby Inc: on 01/12/2007
glittercloud: on 01/12/2007
god. he does appear in northern lights. Golden compass, northern lights. Same book
Reedie_Belacqua: on 01/12/2007
Reedie_Belacqua: on 01/12/2007
I think you forgot lots of things about HDM
or maybe you didn't pay attetion while you were reading? (?)
siiknezz: on 01/15/2007
Buzz: on 01/25/2007
Tarantinoand: on 01/27/2007
AJM: on 01/29/2007
Lyra at heart age 13: on 01/30/2007
Lori: on 01/30/2007
Alanna: on 01/31/2007
Random boy: on 02/03/2007
Random boy: on 02/03/2007
Random boy: on 02/03/2007
left foot james: on 02/03/2007
Lyra116: on 02/04/2007
reachin4thestars: on 02/05/2007
Emily: on 02/08/2007
Emily: on 02/08/2007
L!BBY: on 02/09/2007
4getregret: on 02/10/2007
Isabelle: on 02/13/2007
...: on 02/15/2007
hb: on 02/16/2007
Lyra at heart age 13: on 02/16/2007
Pan_Kirjava_Isabelle: on 02/16/2007
Reedie_Belacqua: on 02/16/2007
a wig would look weird >.<
She could dyed it!
But well....
I gotta confess i prefer her Blond, because i imagined her blond and blue eyes. (and I knew it was wrong, but i couldnt help it)
But, i guess things must be how they should
But, it' nicole kidman!
as i've always said, i've always though she was perfect for the role!!
AND she's a great actrees, SHE'S AWESOME!
Pan_Kirjava_Isabelle: on 02/16/2007
Oh yeah- Will someone shut hb up?!
Lyra at heart age 13: on 02/17/2007
Pan_Kirjava_Isabelle: on 02/17/2007
Wouldn't it be SOOOOO funny if they made Kiera Knightly (or however you spell her name) Mrs.Coulter!
Someone in my school thought they should have....
Weird..... She also thought Lyra should be Dakota Fanning....
Something is SO wrong with her....
Reedie_Belacqua: on 02/17/2007
I would have the urgency of murder them.. ?ɬ?,?ɬ?
I don't like that actrees at all ?Ǭ¨?Ǭ¨'
And Dakota Fanning, she's a great actrees, but a horrible lyra
Pan_Kirjava_Isabelle: on 02/17/2007
Yes, could you just imagine Dakota Fanning as Lyra?! *shudders*
Second thought, don't imagine it!
I like Dakota Fanning in Uptown s, though.
Pan_Kirjava_Isabelle: on 02/17/2007
*Uptown Gurls...
Reedie_Belacqua: on 02/18/2007
I liked the song at the end :) lol
aand molly (molly?) smiles! ~~~
dakota br... i want to see her on move!
i want a trailerrrr
Pan_Kirjava_Isabelle: on 02/18/2007
And I love Molly, too.
I want to see the movie and a trailer SO bad, too!!!
I really can't wait until they pick the guy for Will!!!!!!!!
I've only seen the (fake) trailers on here. They're just bad...
Lyra at heart age 13: on 02/18/2007
: on 02/18/2007
Pan_Kirjava_Isabelle: on 02/18/2007
Uptown Gurls (with an i) is great!!! You have to rent it.
But, can you just imagine Keira....? She's SO skinny and well... just SO not right for the part. It's kinda scary...
Reedie_Belacqua: on 02/18/2007
if they were to do that, would you join with me and go kill them all?
xD
i don't think (in my opinion) that emma watson is a good actress, sorry,
she's over dramatic.. i dunno.
I liked how she looked in the frst movie, but later her hair wasn't messy anymore ?ɬ?,o
Pan_Kirjava_Isabelle: on 02/18/2007
I agree, she is a little too dramatic...
Lyra at heart age 13: on 02/19/2007
above: on 02/19/2007
Pan_Kirjava_Isabelle: on 02/19/2007
Reedie_Belacqua: on 02/23/2007
Lyra_B_S: on 02/24/2007
Pan_Kirjava_Isabelle: on 02/25/2007
Lyra at heart age 13: on 02/25/2007
plaidskirtedheros: on 02/25/2007
plaidskirtedheros: on 02/25/2007
Pan_Kijava_Isabelle: on 03/01/2007
Thor: on 03/06/2007
Agree with the emma wwatson thing- she drives me up the wall. Hermione should be more weird and bushy haired.
Gyptian_Queen: on 03/12/2007
Lyra at heart age 13: on 03/13/2007
Thor: on 03/17/2007
Thor: on 03/17/2007
And just out of interest will they airbrush Dakota when(/if) she gets acne---?
Lyra at heart age 13: on 03/24/2007
above: on 03/24/2007
Thor: on 03/24/2007
Anna (moomin): on 04/13/2007
Anna (moomin): on 04/13/2007
Pan_Kirjava_Isabelle: on 04/13/2007
Lyra at heart age 13: on 04/20/2007
Witch-Queen: on 04/21/2007
Lyra at heart age 13: on 04/22/2007
Pan_Kirjava_Isabelle: on 04/25/2007
Lyra&Pan: on 06/04/2007
Witch_Queen: on 06/07/2007
Lyra&Pan: on 06/07/2007
Lyra&Pan: on 06/10/2007
Lyra&Pan: on 06/11/2007
Lyra&Pan: on 06/12/2007
Lyra&Pan: on 06/13/2007
Lyra&Pan: on 06/15/2007
Lyra&Pan: on 06/16/2007
Fallen Authority: on 06/19/2007
Lyra&Pan: on 06/20/2007
Lyra&Pan: on 06/21/2007
Lyra&Pan: on 06/21/2007
qwertyuiopasdfghjklzxcvbnm: on 06/22/2007
Lyra at heart age 13: on 06/27/2007
Ama: on 07/02/2007
Ama: on 07/06/2007
drama queen: on 07/07/2007
Ama: on 07/09/2007
Ama: on 07/10/2007
Ama: on 07/10/2007
Ama: on 07/11/2007
Ama: on 07/16/2007
Ama: on 07/31/2007
Anyway, what did you guys think of the extended preview? I don't think I've been so excited for this since I first heard it would become a movie!
Ama: on 08/02/2007
If you like the book so much why does it matter what everyone else thinks of it? Why does it matter how Dakota acts *outside* of the movie?
Anyway, at first I wasn't sure about the idea of Freddie Highmore for Pan's voice. But now I'm glad they did it because then we can hear Pan's voice and manner develop as Lyra's does. I also have more faith in the actors for Lee and John Faa. =]
Ama: on 08/05/2007
His looks seem fine for it. But he doesn't seem creepy in the right way. Lol.
Ama: on 08/07/2007
It seems sort of clich?ɬ© if he were in the film though. Everyone would expect it since he seems like such a fantasy type actor...
Ama: on 08/13/2007
^_^: on 09/01/2007
Kalib: on 09/28/2007